Migliaccio & Rathod LLP is investigating whether Panini America has failed to fulfill trading card autograph redemptions within a reasonable period or has provided replacement cards and rewards points worth substantially less than the promised collectibles.
Panini America sells sports trading card products that may contain redemption cards instead of physical autograph cards. Collectors who receive these redemptions can submit them to Panini with the expectation of receiving an autographed card from a particular athlete once it becomes available.
For many collectors, these redemption cards are among the most valuable items that can be obtained from an expensive trading card box. The promised autograph, athlete, rarity, and limited-edition numbering may significantly influence the collectible’s value.
However, some Panini customers have reported waiting months or years after submitting their redemption cards without receiving the promised autographs.
Other collectors have reported being offered replacement cards or rewards points instead of the specific autographed cards they were originally promised. In some instances, consumers believe the substitute merchandise was worth substantially less than the original redemption.
Migliaccio & Rathod is investigating whether Panini has improperly delayed or failed to fulfill autograph redemptions and whether its replacement practices adequately compensate collectors for the merchandise they were promised.
Collectors May Have Experienced:
- Submitting a Panini autograph redemption and waiting months or years for fulfillment;
- Never receiving the specific autographed card identified on the redemption;
- Being offered a different athlete’s card as a replacement;
- Receiving rewards points instead of the promised autograph;
- Being offered substitute merchandise believed to be worth substantially less; or
- Difficulty obtaining updates, refunds, or satisfactory resolutions from Panini.
Potential Claims May Include:
- Failure to provide promised redemption merchandise;
- Breach of applicable contractual or warranty obligations;
- Misrepresentation of autograph redemption benefits;
- Unfair or deceptive replacement practices; or
- Violations of applicable state consumer protection laws.
Signs You May Be Affected:
- You purchased a Panini trading card product containing an autograph redemption;
- You submitted the redemption through Panini’s redemption program;
- You waited an extended period without receiving the promised card;
- You received or were offered a different card or rewards points instead;
- You believe the replacement was worth less than the original autograph; or
- You have your redemption confirmation, original card details, purchase records, or correspondence with Panini.
If you believe you experienced this issue, we would like to hear from you. Please complete the contact form on this page, send us an email at [email protected], or give us a call.
