Topps and Fanatics Autograph Replacement Investigation

Migliaccio & Rathod LLP is investigating whether Topps and Fanatics have failed to fulfill promised autograph redemption cards and have offered store credit or other compensation that does not adequately reflect the value of the original collectibles.

Collectors purchasing premium trading card products may receive redemption cards that promise a specific athlete’s autograph rather than an autographed card physically included in the pack.

These redemptions can be particularly valuable when they involve popular athletes, limited-edition cards, rare parallels, or individually numbered collectibles. Consumers may purchase expensive trading card products partly because of the opportunity to obtain these cards.

However, some Topps and Fanatics customers have reported significant delays in receiving the autographed cards identified in their redemptions.

Other collectors have described being offered FanCash or other forms of store credit instead of the original autograph. For purchasers expecting a particular athlete’s card, store credit may not provide an equivalent replacement because the promised collectible may be unavailable for purchase or have a different market value.

Migliaccio & Rathod is investigating whether Topps and Fanatics have improperly failed to fulfill autograph redemptions and whether their substitute compensation practices deprive collectors of the value of the merchandise they were promised.

Collectors May Have Experienced:

  • Waiting an extended period for a Topps or Fanatics autograph redemption;
  • Never receiving the specific athlete’s autograph identified on the redemption;
  • Being offered FanCash or store credit instead of the promised card;
  • Receiving substitute compensation believed to be worth less than the original collectible;
  • Being unable to obtain a comparable replacement autograph; or
  • Difficulty obtaining clear information about outstanding redemption requests.

Potential Claims May Include:

  • Failure to provide promised autograph redemption merchandise;
  • Breach of applicable contractual or warranty obligations;
  • Misrepresentation of redemption benefits;
  • Unfair or inadequate substitute compensation practices; or
  • Violations of applicable state consumer protection laws.

Signs You May Be Affected:

  • You purchased a Topps and Fanatics trading card product containing an autograph redemption;
  • You submitted the redemption expecting a particular athlete’s card;
  • You did not receive the promised autograph within the expected timeframe;
  • You were offered FanCash, store credit, or a different collectible;
  • You believe the substitute compensation did not reflect the value of the promised card; or
  • You have your redemption confirmation, product details, purchase receipt, or correspondence with Topps or Fanatics.

If you believe you experienced this issue, we would like to hear from you. Please complete the contact form on this page, send us an email at [email protected], or give us a call.

    The following will ask for your contact information so that we may reach you to talk about potential claims. This information is for our records only and will not be shared. By continuing, you consent to the collection of this information for these limited purposes.

    When did you last purchase this product or service (month and year)? Do you have proof of purchase (receipt, email confirmation, transaction on your bank statement, etc.)?

    Please briefly describe the issue with the product or service and when it occurred.

    Stay informed about new class action investigations

    Get email updates about new consumer investigations, potential claims, and developments in ongoing class actions.

    By submitting this form, you consent to receive marketing, updates, and informative SMS messages from Migliaccio & Rathod LLP at the email and/or phone number provided. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or Reply HELP for help. Privacy Policy