PSA Trading Card Grading Accuracy Investigation

Migliaccio & Rathod LLP is investigating whether Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) has inaccurately graded or authenticated certain trading cards, potentially causing collectors to pay for grading services or purchase collectibles based on unreliable assessments of their condition or authenticity.

Professional trading card grading plays an important role in the collectibles market. Collectors pay companies such as PSA to examine trading cards, assess their physical condition, and assign numerical grades that may significantly affect their resale value.

Higher grades can make certain trading cards worth substantially more than otherwise comparable cards in lower condition. Buyers and sellers frequently rely on these grades when deciding how much to pay for a collectible.

However, litigation filed in 2026 raised allegations concerning PSA’s grading practices, including whether certain altered cards received grades inconsistent with the company’s stated standards.

Collectors have also questioned whether grading standards are applied consistently and whether PSA’s evaluations accurately reflect the condition of the cards being examined.

These concerns may be particularly significant for consumers who purchase expensive PSA-graded cards believing that the assigned grade reflects an independent and reliable assessment of the card’s condition.

Migliaccio & Rathod is investigating whether certain PSA grading or authentication practices have caused consumers to pay inflated prices for collectibles, incur unnecessary grading expenses, or otherwise suffer financial losses.

Collectors May Have Experienced:

  • Purchasing a PSA-graded card that appeared to have undisclosed alterations;
  • Discovering that a card’s assigned grade did not accurately reflect its condition;
  • Paying a premium for a collectible based on a PSA grade later called into question;
  • Receiving inconsistent grading results for comparable cards;
  • Experiencing a decline in a card’s value after concerns arose about its grading or authenticity; or
  • Difficulty obtaining a satisfactory resolution after disputing a grading determination.

Potential Claims May Include:

  • Misrepresentation of trading card grading or authentication services;
  • Failure to follow advertised grading standards;
  • Breach of applicable contractual or warranty obligations;
  • Unfair or deceptive business practices; or
  • Violations of applicable state consumer protection laws.

Signs You May Be Affected:

  • You submitted trading cards to PSA for professional grading or authentication;
  • You purchased a PSA-graded collectible based on its assigned grade;
  • You discovered evidence of undisclosed alterations or a potentially inaccurate assessment;
  • The grading issue affected the card’s value or your purchasing decision;
  • You incurred grading fees, paid an inflated purchase price, or suffered another financial loss; or
  • You have the PSA certification number, grading records, purchase receipt, photographs, or correspondence concerning the disputed grade.

If you believe you experienced this issue, we would like to hear from you. Please complete the contact form on this page, send us an email at [email protected], or give us a call.

    The following will ask for your contact information so that we may reach you to talk about potential claims. This information is for our records only and will not be shared. By continuing, you consent to the collection of this information for these limited purposes.

    When did you last purchase this product or service (month and year)? Do you have proof of purchase (receipt, email confirmation, transaction on your bank statement, etc.)?

    Please briefly describe the issue with the product or service and when it occurred.

    Stay informed about new class action investigations

    Get email updates about new consumer investigations, potential claims, and developments in ongoing class actions.

    By submitting this form, you consent to receive marketing, updates, and informative SMS messages from Migliaccio & Rathod LLP at the email and/or phone number provided. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or Reply HELP for help. Privacy Policy