Topps and Fanatics Missing Autograph Investigation

Migliaccio & Rathod LLP is investigating whether Topps and Fanatics have sold premium trading card boxes that fail to contain the guaranteed autograph or memorabilia cards advertised on their packaging or product descriptions.

Collectors frequently purchase premium sports trading card products because they are advertised as containing a specific number of autograph cards, memorabilia cards, or other valuable collectibles. These guaranteed contents can significantly influence a purchaser’s decision to spend hundreds or even thousands of dollars on a trading card box.

However, some Topps customers have reported opening expensive trading card boxes only to discover that the promised autograph cards were missing.

In one 2026 consumer complaint, a purchaser reported spending approximately $5,628.80 on ten Bowman Jumbo boxes, each advertised as containing three autograph cards. According to the complaint, the first three boxes opened contained no autograph cards despite the advertised guarantee.

Other collectors have reported similar concerns involving premium baseball, football, and basketball trading card products.

Migliaccio & Rathod is investigating whether certain Topps and Fanatics trading card products have been sold without their advertised guaranteed contents and whether affected purchasers received adequate replacements, refunds, or other remedies.

Collectors May Have Experienced:

  • Purchasing premium trading card boxes advertised as containing guaranteed autograph cards;
  • Opening boxes that contained fewer autograph cards than promised;
  • Receiving no autograph cards despite an advertised guarantee;
  • Discovering that guaranteed memorabilia cards or other premium inserts were missing;
  • Difficulty obtaining replacement cards or refunds; or
  • Losing the value associated with the guaranteed contents of an expensive trading card purchase.

Potential Claims May Include:

  • Misrepresentation of guaranteed trading card contents;
  • False or misleading product advertising;
  • Breach of express warranty representations;
  • Failure to provide advertised merchandise; or
  • Violations of applicable state consumer protection laws.

Signs You May Be Affected:

  • You purchased a Topps and Fanatics premium trading card box;
  • The packaging or product description guaranteed a specific number of autograph or memorabilia cards;
  • Your box contained fewer guaranteed cards than advertised;
  • You purchased the product based on those guarantees;
  • You were denied an adequate replacement or refund; or
  • You have your purchase receipt, product packaging, photographs, or correspondence with Topps or Fanatics.

If you believe you experienced this issue, we would like to hear from you. Please complete the contact form on this page, send us an email at [email protected], or give us a call.

    The following will ask for your contact information so that we may reach you to talk about potential claims. This information is for our records only and will not be shared. By continuing, you consent to the collection of this information for these limited purposes.

    When did you last purchase this product or service (month and year)? Do you have proof of purchase (receipt, email confirmation, transaction on your bank statement, etc.)?

    Please briefly describe the issue with the product or service and when it occurred.

    Stay informed about new class action investigations

    Get email updates about new consumer investigations, potential claims, and developments in ongoing class actions.

    By submitting this form, you consent to receive marketing, updates, and informative SMS messages from Migliaccio & Rathod LLP at the email and/or phone number provided. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or Reply HELP for help. Privacy Policy